Actual Cash Value, or ACV, is one way an insurance policy can value a roof claim. It pays the cost to replace the roof minus depreciation for its age and wear. In plain terms, ACV reflects what the old roof was worth at the time of the loss, not what a brand-new roof costs. An older roof has depreciated more, so an ACV settlement on it is smaller. Whether your policy pays ACV or full replacement cost is spelled out in your policy.
Insurance policies handle roof claims in one of two main ways, and Actual Cash Value is the more conservative of the two. Under ACV, the insurer figures what it would cost to replace the damaged roof, then subtracts depreciation, an amount reflecting how much life the roof had already used up before the loss.
A ten-year-old roof has given up a chunk of its expected lifespan, so its ACV is well below the price of a new one.
The practical effect is that an ACV settlement leaves a gap between what the insurer pays and what a new roof actually costs, and that gap grows as a roof ages. This is different from Replacement Cost Value coverage, which pays the full cost to replace with a new roof, usually releasing the depreciated portion after the work is done.
Reading which type your policy carries before a storm ever hits is one of the most useful things you can do as a homeowner.
A few honest points to keep in mind. The homeowner files and owns the claim, and the deductible is always the homeowner's responsibility, regardless of whether the policy pays ACV or replacement cost.
Coverage is never guaranteed, since every policy and claim is different. A roofer can document the damage with photos and a written report and meet your adjuster on site to point out what was found, but the roofer does not file, negotiate, or guarantee your claim and is not a public adjuster.
For the specifics of how your policy values a claim, your insurer or agent is the right source.
A free, documented inspection across the Triangle. A real estimator within the hour.